Bird25's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[-Swirl!-]

0:00-0:13: 10/10. Nice intro. I love the upbeat rhythm that lasts throughout the song.
0:14-0:27: 10/10. Love the melody and instrument.
0:28-0:54: 9/10. Like this part, but don't know what it was meant to be. A drop, maybe?
0:55-1:22: 10/10. Love the key change. That's why I put the whole thing in here; because it really combines.
1:23-1:37: 10/10. Love the new melody along with the new key.
1:38-2:03: 9/10. Again, like it, but what were you trying to do with it?
2:04-3:24: 7/10. Nice but repetitive.
3:25-3:52: 10/10. Love the recovery.
3:53-4:07: 10/10. Love this part. The new rhythm is nice.
4:08-4:33: 9/10. Still, what are you trying to do with it? It doesn't really matter because it's awesome nevertheless.
4:34-4:55: 10/10. Love the ending.

[TheFatRat - Xenogenesis]

0:00-0:18: 10/10: Very nice and beautiful way to start off a piece.
0:19-0:31: 10/10: Love the added "Response".
0:32-0:58: 10/10: Awesome way to lead to a drop.
0:59-1:24: 10/10: Nice drop, I like the instruments.
1:25-1:50: 4/10: I really just don't get this part. Love the rest of the song but this part just dosesn't seem to fit in.
1:51-2:18: 9/10: Nice, but the same as the last drop.
2:19-2:44: 10/10: Very beautiful part. Love it!
2:45-3:10: 9/10: Good way to get back into it, but same as last lead.
3:11-3:37: 9/10: Still the same drop... Still love it though.
3:38-3:53: 10/10: Love the ending.

[Microcosm]

Nice song. A little repetitive and seems to decay later in the song, but I like the rhythm and beat.

Geoplex responds:

Yeah, been getting the repetitive comment a bit - I tried to make it more consistent, but maybe I went a bit overboard. Thanks for the feedback!

[Nothing But Sand & Water]

0:00-0:12: 8/10: Nice intro, but repetitive.
0:13-0:32: 9/10: Like this part. Very relaxing.
0:33-1:00: 10/10: Awesome and relaxing. This part makes it one of the best GD custom songs ever. Closest competitors are Glorious Morning and Swirl.
1:01-1:18: 10/10: Love this part, almost a segway.
1:19-1:39: 9/10: Nice, but slightly repetitive background that should be slightly softer.
1:40-2:00: 10/10: Great part. Love the whistle.
2:01-2:20: 10/10: Similar but different to first "drop", and just as good.
2:21-2:37: 9/10: Abrupt but nice ending.

[-Clownparty remix-]

Not very good. Just sounds kinda disturbing to me. Most of your other songs are much better.

[-Geometrical Dominator-]

0:00-0:06: 9/10: Nice start.
0:07-0:19: 10/10: Very good. Works well with GD and is awesome in general.
0:20-0:32: 7/10: Ok, but not very detailed and a little bland.
0:33-0:45: 9/10: Like this part, but still very slightly bland.
0:46-1:04: 10/10: Love this part, especially the connecting rhythm.
1:05-1:18: 10/10: Extremely awesome. Love the whistle. Best part of the song.
1:06-1:31: 9/10: Good, but slightly strange.
1:32-1:44: 10/10: Good ending. Makes you want to listen to the song again.

[-Glorious morning-]

0:00-0:12: 10/10. Very calm and beautiful way to start off a piece. I love the bird calls, of course.
0:13-0:25: 10/10. Still very beautiful and nice. Love the flute!
0:26-0:38: 9/10. A good way to lead to a drop, but very slightly boring. Still good.
0:39-0:51: 9/10. Nice drop, but a little repetitive.
0:52-1:03: 10/10. Awesome. Love the beat, the instruments, and the sound.
1:04-1:16: 10/10. Even better way to lead to the second drop.
1:17-1:28: 9/10. Second drop very good. Less repetitive within, but a little too similar to the first drop.
1:29-1:41: 10/10. Love it. Very nice way to lead to the end. I doubt you could improve this part.
1:42-1:51: 9/10. Nice, but a little strange.